SMART goals can look “organized” and still pull you in the wrong direction. When goals become a task list with deadlines, you get motion, not advantage. This article shows the shift from goals-as-chores to goals-as-bets—so your effort finally moves the scoreboard.
On a Monday night, Mara joined a goal setting webinar from her phone.
She’s an HR manager in a fast-growing company. The kind of role where your job is to “fix the people problems” while pretending you don’t have any.
Her camera was off. Her kids were finally asleep. She told herself, “This is my reset.”
Two hours later, she had twelve “SMART goals,” a clean template, and a quiet panic she couldn’t explain.
Because the goals looked organized… but they didn’t feel like a way to win.
The promise is clarity. The aftertaste is pressure.
Goal setting webinars often feel good while you’re inside them. The speaker is confident. The framework is tidy. The steps feel like certainty.
But the moment the session ends, real life walks back in—emails, meetings, shifting priorities, and a calendar that doesn’t care about your intentions.
So the frustration doesn’t show up as drama. It shows up as heaviness.
You try to do the goals, and it feels like pushing a cart uphill while your life keeps adding groceries.
“SMART” often means “task list with deadlines.”
Many SMART goals are not smart at all.
They’re tasks dressed up as strategy.
They look like: “Complete this.” “Finish that.” “Attend this training.” “Launch this initiative.” “Post three times a week.” They’re measurable, sure. They’re time-bound, yes. But they aren’t bets.
A bet has a point. A bet has a win condition. A bet is a choice that says, “This is where we’re placing our chips because we believe it will move the scoreboard.”
A task is just activity. And activity feels productive… until you realize you’re busy in the wrong direction.
Nico’s SMART goals weren’t wrong. They were small.
Nico is a sales team lead. Reliable, driven, and tired in a very quiet way.
In a goal setting session, he wrote SMART goals like a good student. Increase follow-ups. Improve pipeline hygiene. Conduct weekly coaching. Track conversion rates.
All good.
Then Q1 ended and he felt behind anyway, even though he was doing more than ever. When we looked closer, the problem wasn’t effort. The problem was the question he never asked.
He was answering, “What should I do?”
He wasn’t answering, “How do we win?”
So his goals became a checklist, not a bet. It was productivity without positioning.
The biggest miss: people don’t know what “winning” looks like.
This is where most goal setting webinars quietly fail people. They assume the person already has a clear aspiration. They assume you know what winning actually means.
But many professionals don’t.
They know what they’re supposed to deliver. They know what their boss expects. They know what’s urgent.
What they don’t have is a clear, shared definition of win.
So they set goals that sound responsible, but they don’t create advantage. They fill the calendar, but they don’t move the scoreboard.
And because the environment keeps changing, the goals start to feel fragile. You set them in January. Reality rewrites them by February.
That’s not because you planned badly.
It’s because you planned without a strategy.
Aira built a beautiful goal dashboard. It still didn’t help her win.
Aira is a project manager. The team runs on her follow-ups. She’s the kind of person people call “high potential” right before they give her more work.
After a webinar, she built a goal system that looked like a productivity influencer’s dream: dashboards, trackers, weekly reviews, color codes.
But her days didn’t change. She still spent most of her time reacting. She still felt trapped in other people’s priorities.
When she looked at her goals, she didn’t feel guided.
She felt judged.
Because her goals were designed as tasks to complete, not bets to win. She wasn’t playing to win. She was trying not to fall behind.
Stop asking “What goals should I set?” and start asking the right five questions.
This is why I don’t treat goal setting as the starting point.
Goal setting is downstream.
The upstream work is strategy—knowing where to place your effort so it creates leverage, even when the environment changes.
And this is where the five questions matter. Not as a business-school exercise, but as a practical way to stop guessing and start choosing.
Here they are, in human language:
1) What’s our real aspiration? Not “what do we want to do,” but “what does winning look like for us?” If you can’t say it in one or two sentences, you will drown in options.
2) Where will we play? Which customers, markets, projects, roles, or arenas will you focus on—and which ones will you stop chasing?
3) How will we win there? What is your advantage? What will you do differently so you’re not just working harder than everyone else?
4) What capabilities must we build? What skills, systems, relationships, or assets must become true so winning becomes likely?
5) What management systems keep this alive? What rhythms, reviews, metrics, and habits will keep the strategy from dying under daily chaos?
When people start here, their goals change shape. They stop looking like errands.
They start looking like bets.
Goals don’t survive an environment that rewards the opposite.
Paolo is an operations supervisor. He wants to get healthier. He writes it every year.
But his workplace rewards “always on.” Late nights get praised. Rest gets mocked. He’s surrounded by signals that say: if you slow down, you’re not serious.
So his health goals weren’t just hard. They were incompatible with how his life was built.
Once he named that, the solution wasn’t “try harder.” The solution was to choose where to play and how to win inside the reality he had.
He didn’t aim for a perfect plan. He placed a bet he could sustain.
He chose one window, two days a week, and a simple system that didn’t require a new personality.
Goals as bets, not chores.
If you want to keep SMART goals, fine—but upgrade them. Before you make them Specific and Measurable, make them Strategic.
Ask: “What are we betting on?” and “Why will this help us win?”
Because a goal that doesn’t connect to a clear aspiration is just motion. A goal that doesn’t reflect trade-offs is just wishful thinking. A goal that doesn’t build advantage is just busy work with metrics.
And in an ever-changing environment, busy work is the fastest path to burnout.
Convert one SMART goal into a real bet.
Pick one SMART goal you wrote recently.
Then run it through two questions:
What are we trying to win at? Why is this the best bet right now?
If you can’t answer those, you don’t have a goal. You have a task.
Now rewrite it as a bet by adding the missing strategy:
- Start with a clear aspiration (one sentence).
- Name where you’ll play (what you will focus on, and what you will ignore).
- Define how you’ll win (your advantage).
- Turn the goal into a capability you must build.
- Lock it with one management rhythm (a weekly review, a scorecard, a calendar block).
Do this once and you’ll feel the difference immediately. The goal won’t feel like pressure.
It will feel like direction.
And that’s the real win: not a prettier goal list, but a clearer way to win—even when the ground keeps moving.
If your team is stuck in meetings, misalignment, or slow decisions…
Let’s design one shift they can use immediately.
→ Shift Experiences
